Best QB of all time

[Caliyak]

So we have Bradshaw, Montana and Brady with 4 rings. So, who is the greatest?

[Mr T-rex]

Montana is 4-0 so undefeated will be the greatest of all time and i am also a 49er fan lol

[City Dad]

Elway......

[MarkyMark]

1. Montana 2. Bradshaw 3. Brady

[cutbait]

Elway..

You cannot speak of ring totals or undefeatedNess and rank QB solely by them.


Throw Elway on those 9er teams and he does better.

Marini too.


Not taking anything from Bradshaw or Montana but fortunes of being on dynastys should be weighed accordingly

[Caliyak]

I agree with Elway. Also add Aikman, Kelly and Young. But, if we go with qbs with 4 rings, different eras and each qb is great within their own era.

[cutbait]

It's certainly not cut and dry.



Whereas in Baseball best hitter is a given.

Ted Williams

[DockRat]

Joe Montana.....

[muskyman]

My favorite QB or style of playing would be Randall Cunningham. I liked his style.

[MustHuntAndFish]

Throw Elway on those 9er teams and he does better.

You're delusional... Elway was physically stronger but that's all he had on Montana. Joe was pin point accurate and had total command of the offense. You talk like Montana was carried by his defense or running game. It was Elway that couldn't win it all until he had Terrell Davis.

Montana and Brady are the only 2 in the conversation. Peyton would be but he never came up big in the playoffs.